SDT Lean Fair Project Evaluation

The size and the color of the letters are adequate

The amount of information in the presentation was adequate

The presentation is arranged in a coherent, logic and clear way

The information presented is relevant and pertinent to the project

The presentation included visual aid ( photos, graphs, diagrams, etc.)

The oral presentation was clear, fluid and with an adequate tone

The presenter captured the interest and attention of the audiences

The presentation was made in a creative and original way

The lean tool selected was the correct one for the prob presented

The team demonstrated full knowledge in the tool used

The problem definition answered the basic question (what, when, where, who and how)

The business case was directed to attend a business need

An investigation was performed and acquired data that support possible causes

The team was effective identifying the potential root cause of the problem

Key criteria were used in the process for the data collection

A Process map or process data was used to understand the current state and identified the opportunities

An statistical analysis of the data was performed

The conclusions obtained attended the reduction or elimination of the problem

Prioritization criteria was shown for the selection of the possible solutions based on the conclusion

The process was standardized and it shows a sustainable improvement

The team implemented the 5S methodology

The team implemented CIL methodology

It is evident the use of different visual aids (boards, standard work, Kansan, Centerlines, etc)

A cost analysis vs benefit was performed and it shows the viability of the project

There is evidence of a considerable reduction in some of the 8 wastes

There is evidence of a considerable reduction in operation costs

There is evidence of considerable improvement in any of the KPI’s

The expected benefits were obtained in the project

There is evidence of some benefit in another area like safety, environmental, workplace environment, etc.

These benefit were estimated or quantified

The solution was reapplied to other areas

The necessary resources were identified to implement the project (MOC, budget, time, etc.)

Key personnel were involved and participated of the process in the implementation plan

The implementation of the project with the expected scope was achieved

Additional alternatives were evaluated in cases where the identified solution could not be implemented